Introduction

McDonald’s and Starbucks are two of the world’s most recognized consumer brands, each with a powerful global footprint. As dividend investors look for consistent income and long-term growth, the question arises: which stock offers the better combination of value, dividend yield, and sustainability in 2025? This comprehensive analysis compares McDonald’s and Starbucks to help you decide which dividend stock deserves a place in your portfolio.

---

1. Valuation: Is MCD or SBUX More Attractively Priced?

We begin by examining the Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio, which shows how much investors are paying for each dollar of earnings. Lower ratios may indicate undervaluation.

Year	MCD P/E	SBUX P/E
2020	33.1	35.5
2021	32.4	33.7
2022	31.6	32.9
2023	30.8	30.5
2024	30.1	29.8
2025	29.9	29.1

Valuation Verdict:
Both companies trade at relatively high P/E ratios, reflecting investor confidence in their brands. However, Starbucks is slightly cheaper than McDonald’s in 2025, potentially offering more upside for value-conscious investors.

---

2. Dividend Yield and Growth: Who Pays More?

Dividend yield tells us how much income we can expect from our investment. But for long-term returns, we also consider the growth in dividends over time.

Year	MCD Yield	SBUX Yield
2020	2.5%	1.8%
2021	2.4%	1.7%
2022	2.3%	1.9%
2023	2.4%	2.0%
2024	2.5%	2.2%
2025	2.6%	2.3%
6-Year Avg	2.45%	1.98%

5-Year Dividend Growth (CAGR):
MCD: 7.4%
SBUX: 8.6%

Dividend Analysis:
McDonald’s consistently offers a higher yield than Starbucks, appealing to income-focused investors. However, Starbucks shows stronger dividend growth, making it more attractive for those seeking long-term compounding returns.

---

3. Dividend Sustainability: Can the Payouts Continue?

The payout ratio reveals how much of a company’s earnings go toward dividends. A ratio under 80% is generally considered safe and sustainable.

Year	MCD Payout	SBUX Payout
2020	72%	66%
2021	68%	59%
2022	69%	63%
2023	68%	65%
2024	69%	66%
2025	70%	67%

Sustainability Verdict:
Both McDonald’s and Starbucks maintain healthy payout ratios, with Starbucks having slightly more room to grow. McDonald’s has a longer dividend history, but Starbucks shows disciplined growth with sustainable payouts.

---

Conclusion: Which Dividend Stock Wins in 2025?

Let’s summarize the key insights from this dividend showdown:

• Valuation: Starbucks is slightly more affordable.
• Dividend Yield: McDonald’s offers a higher yield.
• Dividend Growth: Starbucks grows faster.
• Payout Ratio: Both are solid; Starbucks has more cushion.

Final Verdict:
If you’re focused on immediate income, McDonald’s (MCD) remains a top-tier dividend stock with consistency and stability. However, for total return and long-term dividend growth, Starbucks (SBUX) is the compelling choice for 2025. Growth-oriented dividend investors may prefer Starbucks, while conservative income investors may lean toward McDonald’s. There is another interesting article where I wrote about the foodstocks Kimberly Clarck versus Proctor and Gamble. Here you can read the comparison.

Disclaimer: This analysis is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Always do your own research or consult a financial advisor before investing.